Social Selling Psych 101: Maximizing Conversions on Meta & TikTok
Skip to Content

Social Selling Psychology 101:
Maximizing Conversions on Meta, TikTok, & More 

What do psychology, business, and social selling have in common? Quite a lot, actually—at least if you’re doing it right. Whether or not you snoozed through your psych 101 class in school, we’ve got some vital notes to share about how you can apply buyer psychology to your marketing campaigns to maximize conversions!  

Here, we’ll touch on: 

  • The 4 Buyer Modalities: Understanding the most common ways humans make decisions. 
  • Marketing to Each Modality: How modalities should guide your messaging and marketing strategy.  
  • Examples of Social Selling to Modalities on Meta & TikTok Shop: See some of the campaigns and creative Agital has used to drive real-life results for our clients.  
  • Mapping the Right Modalities Through Segmentation: How segmentation can help you identify and apply your audiences’ modalities most effectively to boost conversions. 

Keep reading to unlock actionable insights guaranteed to improve your marketing results. Or, if you’d rather listen/watch and learn, you can check out our on-demand webinar:

Using Psychology to Sell on Meta & TikTok

The 4 Buyer Modalities

Marketing automation tools offer a host of features designed to optimize lead Let’s begin our dive into modalities with a disclaimer: “buyers”, “customers”, “users”, “leads”, and “prospects” are all—first and foremost—people, and people rarely fit neatly or completely into a single category. Humans are beautifully diverse and complex, and we all have varying levels of all four modalities (aka “temperaments”) explored below. 

With that in mind, buyer modalities are a phenomenal starting point for understanding the psychology of human behavior and scaling personalized communication that drives conversion! Modalities help brands become leaders. So, let’s explore the four modalities, or the ways that people are driven to act—and buy. 

1. Competitive (aka Choleric)

What’s the bottom line?

Sometimes referred to as a type A personality, competitive buyers are in it to win it and get a thrill out of being (and having) the best. To them, life is survival of the fittest and they put a lot of energy into making sure that they stay ahead of everybody else. Competitive personality types seek to take charge of situations and present themselves as leaders. 

Michael Phelps, Serena Williams, and Mark Zuckerberg exhibit competitive personality traits. They are driven, focused, and famous for the hard work that went into creating their careers. 

Decision-Making: Based more on logic than emotion. Fast to purchase.

Effective Competitive Ads Often Include:

  • Heavy/Dramatic Creative 
  • Showcase Influencers 
  • Use Competitive Language 
  • Emphasize Limited Production/Premium Price 

Tactics for Selling to a Competitive Audience

  • Target “Best” Phrases: Foster the “best” customer experiences and optimize content to rank for “best” searches with reviews, proof points, and stories to prove how/why. 
  • Loyalty Programs: Incorporate exciting loyalty program focused on status (vs spontaneous about points). 
  • Influencer Endorsements: Define the aspirational user of your product and seek influencer endorsements from leaders in their craft. 

Examples: Competitive Marketing on Meta

Examples: Competitive Marketing on TikTok Shop

2. Spontaneous (aka Phlegmatic)

Why should I choose you NOW? 

Also known as a type B personality, spontaneous buyers live for the fun of it. They don’t care too much about competition, but they love the exciting feeling they get when doing something new or unexpected. 

Walt Disney, Jim Carrey, and Lady Gaga are said to be examples of spontaneous personality types, because they are all well-known for their strong sense of creativity, imagination, and extraversion. 

Decision-Making: Based mostly on emotion. Fast to purchase. 

Effective Spontaneous Ads Often Include:

  • Eye-Popping Color 
  • Prominent Banners on Site, Ads, Email 
  • Countdowns Before & During 
  • Discount Calculation & # Left on PDP 

Tactics for Selling to a Spontaneous Audience

  • First Purchase Offer: Target cold and warm audiences with a first-time offer they can’t refuse. 
  • Mega Sale: Offer a big discount—in big font and bold colors—on your site and across all owned and paid media. 
  • New Products/Low Supply: Appeal to active, loyal buyers by emphasizing a limited supply of new products. 

Examples: Spontaneous Marketing on Meta

Examples: Spontaneous Marketing on TikTok Shop

3. Methodical (aka Melancholic)

How does your process or product work? 

Methodical buyers crave information. They don’t feel comfortable making a decision until they analyze all the facts. They are “data” people who do their due diligence to predict the outcome of every choice or purchase. They care about the quality and accuracy of their decisions. 

Albert Einstein, Bill Gates, and C-3PO from Star Wars are good examples of methodical personality types. 

Decision-Making: Based on logic. Slow to purchase.  

Effective Methodical Ads Often Include:

  • Product Finder Tool 
  • Emphasis on Brand/Site Value Props 
  • Product Guarantee (Fitment, Compatibility) 
  • Features & Comparison 

Tactics for Selling to a Methodical Audience

  • Buyer’s Guides: Provide content that guides your buyers through decision-making, just as an expert salesperson might in person. 
  • Features/Benefits-Focused Chatbox: Create a chatbox focused on customer features, benefits, and guarantees. 
  • Problem-Based Search: Share your problem/solution-focused customer stories and optimize your content to rank for “problem” searches and prove your solution. 

Examples: Methodical Marketing on Meta

Examples: Methodical Marketing on TikTok Shop

4. Social (aka Humanistic, Sanguine) 

Who used your solution to solve my problem? 

Social personalities care intensely about the people around them and tend to put the needs of others ahead of their own. They focus on how other people feel and will go to great lengths to maintain a happy and healthy environment for everyone around them. 

Celebrity philanthropists like Princess Diana, Dolly Parton, and Oprah Winfrey are all examples of social personality types because they are famous for helping others, especially those less fortunate than themselves. 

Decision-Making: Based on emotion. Slow to purchase. 

Effective Social Ads Often Include:

  • Invest in Review System for Products 
  • Update Search & Product Ads With Reviews 
  • Convert Reviews Into Ads 
  • Chatbot & Phone Support 
  • Feature Customer Quotes or Case Study Stats 

Tactics for Selling to a Social Audience

  • Testimonial Ads: Circulate punchy testimonials in your ads and on your site. 
  • Brand Trust Ratings: Aggregate your ratings and launch visibility in your search, owned, and paid ads. 
  • Product Rating: Showcase product ratings in Google PLA and in email/SMS. 

Examples: Social Marketing on Meta

Examples: Social Marketing on TikTok Shop

Bonus TikTok Tip: Live Shopping Appeals to Spontaneous & Social Personas

Marketing Through the Funnel for Each Modality

The table below shows how modalities can guide your messaging at each stage of the funnel or buyer’s journey (awareness, consideration, conversion, and loyalty). 

Mapping the Right Modalities Through Segmentation

Although each person represents different levels of each temperament, most of us align with a primary modality. Same goes for your audience. And that’s good, because focusing on one modality at a time eliminates 75% of the time and effort needed to implement your most effective social selling strategies. 

The best way to align your prospects and customers with modalities at scale is to leverage marketing segmentation and map your audience segments to their respective modalities.  

What is audience segmentation and why do it?

Audience segmentation is the process of dividing your customers into groups based on common characteristics, so you can market to each group most effectively. Segmentation allows marketers to better tailor our efforts to various audience subsets through messaging and offers that are most likely to resonate with them. 

Agital’s 3-Step Approach for Mapping Modalities to Segments

  1. Identify Your Key Segments  
  1. Map Each Segment to a Primary Modality 
  1. Build a Modality Library to Test Tactics & Save Winners 

1. Identify Your Key Segments

Use historical data about your contact lists—including purchase history, past interactions, and campaign engagement—to group your contacts by common characteristics. Depending on the data available, you can segment them by any of the following factors. 

Factors for Segmentation 

  • Demographic: Gender, age, occupation, household income, marital status, etc. 
  • Geographic: location, language, cultural factors, climate, etc. 
  • Psychographic: interests, hobbies, lifestyle, values, personality traits, motivators, etc. 
  • Lifestyle: Profession, habits, activities, preferences, etc. 

2. Map Each Segment to a Primary Modality

Once you have your segments determined, try to make educated guesses about each segment’s modality, and then test your theories! This is a great opportunity to A/B test different types of messaging and creative. You might be able to verify your inferences or learn something new and important about one of your customer segments.  

When you are confident about each segment’s primary modality, you’ll find it infinitely easier to create effective marketing campaigns that drive conversions across every channel. 

As an example (and for funsies), here are some popular fictional characters we have mapped to the four modalities:  

3. Build a Modality Library to Test & Save Winning Tactics 

Begin building and testing the creative and messaging assets you expect will appeal most to your audience segments and their primary modalities. Make sure you document your efforts and organize your assets by modality to simplify future campaigns.  

Then, once you know which modalities align with each segment, you have an easy pool of resources to leverage and look to for inspiration moving forward.

Ready to pass social selling psych 101?

Hopefully our thorough review has you ready to apply segmentation and modalities to slay your social selling strategy! Keep in mind that A/B testing is encouraged, and it’s always okay to ask for help. Agital partners with TikTok Shop, Meta, and various other leading social media and ecommerce marketing platforms to ensure our clients get the most value out of every campaign, and we would be thrilled to help you.  

We also offer a free ecommerce audit and growth plan to level up your marketing performance across all your digital channels—from social media to paid search, and even Shopify—to identify opportunities to optimize your results. We’ll help you harness the power of selling psychology to maximize your growth in no time if you contact us today. 

subscribe

Subscribe to the marketing revolution.